Using the film Blade Runner for GCSE English.
Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?
Bladerunner was based on the book Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K Dick.
|While the director, Ridley
Scott, gave a great sense of depth to the film by adding layers of images
to create a complex world he also simplified the story, omitting many of
the features of the book.
Dick's story has more threads to the narrative but these threads cannot be so easily portrayed in the medium of film. Even with the omissions made by Ridley Scott the producers felt it necessary to add a voice-over by Harrison Ford to explain some aspects of the story. The Director's Cut deletes this as unnecessary
The following features appear in the book but not in the film >
A mysterious virtual reality character
called Mercer symbolises religion as followed by the inhabitants
of Earth at this time. People reach him wearing virtual reality gear and
experience some religious feelings while being pelted with falling rocks
Deckard has a wife who is suffering from depression. She uses a machine called the Penfold Empathy Box which changes her emotions artificially.
In the story very realistic artificial animals have largely replaced the very few remaining real creatures. Owning a real animal holds extremely high status.
A male character called Isidore holds "special chickenhead status" signifying that he is mentally deficient in some ways. In the story he takes the role which J R Sebastian plays in the film, acting as an intermediary for the androids because they promise to be his friends.
There are originally 8 androids in the book.
One of the androids is an opera singer called Luba Loft - in some ways equivalent to Zelda in the film.
Other androids include Baty (here named Imgard Baty rather than Roy), Polokov and Garland. The latter works from a bogus police headquarters. He takes some of the role of Bryant.
There is an expressed view by the group of androids that they must use hallucinogenic drugs to create a sense of religion. Compare this with the film in which the group's purpose is to find out where they came from in order to determine and lengthen their life span.
In the book Rachel is much more independent and is specifically described as intending to help Deckard to defeat the androids. In the film she does shoot Leon to save Deckard.
The language of the book has been changed in the film. Where Deckard is a "Bladerunner" in the film here he is simply a bounty hunter; "replicants" are here known as "andys".
Whereas the final showdown with Baty is hugely important in the film, it is an insignificant gunfight which is quickly over in the book.
The three final chapters have Deckard going
out into the wilderness, returning to his wife with an electric toad.
Questions posed by the book ...
At the core of the book is the question:
"what does it mean to be human?"
Luba has a great voice but she's an android. Rachael did not know at first that she was an android.
Phil Resch, the other bounty hunter thought he himself might be an android (though it turned out that he wasn't). For simple minded Isidore it doesn't matter, because he has friends.
Rachel is the same android model as Pris - but in some ways they are different.
Can Deckard "retire" Pris and still love Rachel?
Can electric sheep and electric toads have any kind of life on their own?
The original book has a more complex narrative, more characters and plot threads, but these are simplified or built in to the mise en scene in the film.
Tom Cleaver wrote to me after reading this page, and disagreed with some of what I'd written.
If you've read this page so far you might like to read his different view.
Think about the differences between what we have written. Which are differences of fact and which are differences of opinion?
Which do you agree with?